Wednesday, January 18, 2017

The last days

It's Robbin writing now.  Deb has simply had enough ALS.  I'm writing to chronicle how her story ends.  I've told a half dozen people over the phone or in person and it is so very difficult to have the same conversation with individuals.  By writing the this, I'm telling her story and saving myself from a fresh retelling each time I think of someone else I know is dear to her.  Conversely, she is dear to almost everyone she's befriended and I'd either become toughened to the story or I'd be a complete mess.  I'll add entries as time goes on to keep everybody informed.

Let me tell what led her to decide to quit eating, if taking green glop laced with supplements, drugs and another dozen organic ingredients though a feeding tube embedded in her stomach can be called eating.

Last October and November, she gave up on medical treatments.  Her last (second) trip to North Carolina was too much to repeat monthly.  Taking 3 helpers to get her to the airport, to whisk her through the airport, on and off the toilet in a ladies restroom, on the plane and then off, into a rented car to a hotel and then to the clinic and back.  It was too much for her.  The stem cell benefits were not worth the trouble.  She came back completely wiped out.  She decided hospice care would give her greater comfort.

Comfort is truly a subjective state.  Imagine existing in a body that allowed you to nod your head, blink your eyes and make only a moan sound.  A moan that goes up fast means you're doing something she doesn't want.  Going down means no.  Silence is assent.  She is not comfortable by any measure.  The worst of it is, she's mentally sharp as a tack.

Yet she couldn't let go of communicating what she wanted.  For a long time we read her lips as best we could and we've all said ABCs so she could nod to the desired letter.  Remember in her natural,  healthy state, she communicated vocally at maybe 1000 letters per second and now she was communicating at 2 or 3 letters per minute.  If you know Deb, who used to reach down my throat to pull the words out of my slow talking mouth, 2 letters per minute is nearly unacceptable, yet attainable.  Oh it used to get my goat when her first word was WHEN.  Lots of ABCs in that word.

There are a lot of parts of her that needed fine adjustments we all take for granted.  A leg needing to moved a half inch right, an arm with a little stress on her elbow needing movement.  Drool needing a little wipe.  Hot hands, cold hands.  Knees up and then down. Nothing she could do from within could alleviate her discomfort. She could move nothing but her eyes and She is completely dependent on her care givers.  And they gave until it hurt.  They too have tender hearts right now.  These are my second wives.

As you know, she gets people to love her without trying.  In point of fact, one of her regrets is that these care givers will be unemployed soon.  This time should be absolutely and completely about her, yet she's concerned that they get good recommendations as they move on.  That's my Deb.

2 weeks ago (about January 3 or 4) she decided she wanted to be gone by the following Sunday.  She wanted me to find the right cocktail of her prodigious collection of drugs would let her go quickly and painlessly.  I was stunned but not surprised.  Intellectual me says she's probably right.  Given that she has  10% - 20% lung function an sometimes gasping for air, she found drowning in her own fluids repugnant.  Emotional me, asks can I do it?  Intellectual me asks what are the consequences?  A real debate was going through my mind.  Risks?  Worst outcome:  I could have supported her these last 7 years and my reward could be a jail cell.  I've watched too much Law and Order.  I couldn't have done it, for the record.

My conclusion was that this is a Lucy Ricardo scheme.  Lucy was the star of I Love Lucy, a sitcom from the 50's and rerun for the next 60 years here in America.  Every episode's plot was that Lucy had a scheme to achieve her goal (money, fame, etc), but she never considered the consequences of her schemes.  Rarely did it turn out how she imagined.  Deb's overdose plan was a quintessential Lucy scheme.

I contacted a friend whose wife was a long time hospice nurse.  She put us in touch with a person who gave this kind of advice and if we contacted her, Deb could learn her LEGAL options.  My plan was to give Deb the options I learned.  Before this could happen, I let on what research I was doing.

In very typical Deb fashion, she took over.  She wrote to the hospice nurse and was on the phone asking questions and getting the information directly.  When the phone call was over at 8pm on Sunday night, we were immediately contacting the end of life specialist.

Asking questions is a bit of a misnomer.  Deb hasn't enunciated a word in a year.  Lack of breath and  motor control of her mouth parts (and nearly every one of her other parts) means speaking was a lost skill for her.  However her computer that read her eye movements allowed her to type, so her questions were spoken by the computer (itself disconcerting because the computer didn't have a New York accent and spoke rather slowly, hardly the avatar she would have chosen).  The long and short of it, Deb's only choice was to refuse nourishment and water and wait with hospice support for the calming drugs they routinely prescribe.

How many of us could do this?  And a day into it, how many would continue the vigil?  Not me.  She has morphine and adavan.  Does she do this?  Even when I tell her if she does it regularly it would build up and help her in the comfort department.  Oh, no.  My Deb only has it when she wants and not frequent enough for my taste.

She is not comatose just yet.  She's awake only 6 hours a day, but I don't think she's comfortable.  If she only said, feed me, there would be a all hands on deck to revive her.  She has an iron will to do this.  She wants this enough to go through it.  That is absolutely crystal clear to all of us.

Fucking A, this is hardest on her, but knowing this is what she wants is almost unbearable for me too.  Probably only slightly easier for her care givers.  She has gotten close to all her care givers.  Daughter close (they're mostly young).  They love her too.  So we all acquiesce and give her our love and support.

Ever the organizer and control exerter, Deb has made lists of tasks for me to accomplish during and after this tragic episode.  One was to keep this secret until the end.  I can't say I agree with the secrecy and lord knows, I couldn't possibly keep separate versions of information straight in my head.  It is more my style to have one story, stick to the truth and let that be my mistake rather than try to remember who is supposed to know what.  Thus this blog.

I talked to her former Basel boss and it was a stilted conversation.  I hit her right between the eyes with it and, even knowing this call would eventually come, I still shocked her.  I believe that me writing this blog and giving you stories and omitting the gory details will help you process this.  I'm in no state to shock people and then provide details.

I invite you to share anything you care to in comments.  I'd rather celebrate her successes and good deeds than focus on this end stage.  She's touched so many people, I can't begin to reach you all.  Please pass this URL around.  Tell us all favorite Deb stories.  Especially stuff I've never heard before.  It would be helpful for me and any who remember her.

I'll write about how I'm dealing with this in a subsequent post.  I'm not all right, but even given that I support her completely.  Its not what I want her to do.  Half a Deb is better than no Deb at all.  I told her this.  And I got off a love letter while she was lucid, although not eloquent, made her weep for hours.  She knows my undying love for her, but reading the words warmed her greatly.  This is all I can do - make her comfortable.

Logistically, when she is gone, I intend to have her cremated and make the urn myself on my lathe.  It will be a double urn so I can be added and then poor Ryan will have the job.  Sorry Ryan, let's hope it is a good long time from now.  I'll eventually tell you how religion played a part in her life so you'll understand the lack of a service.  I'll have an open house for visitors for a couple of weekends.  I'm happy to welcome all visitors and can accommodate sleep overs - we're way the hell out in the sticks and it isn't an easy trip, but any who make it will receive Deb hospitality.  She taught me well.  

15 comments:

  1. Posted by Mary Ellen Clark:

    Oh Robbin and Ryan, my heart goes out to you both. Thank you for sharing your beautiful blog and thank you for sharing Deb with us all. You wanted Deb stories – there are so many – Deb and I first learned we were both quilters at an SAP training class at Roche. She said “I like you, but I don’t have time for new friends”, which I always loved reminding her that she said! Of course, in typical Deb fashion, that was so far from the truth – she always had time for her friends. We went to the Lancaster Quilt Convention every year for several years, staying in motels or bed and breakfasts together, staying up late at night like a teenaged pajama party talking and giggling. We went to see Leon Russell together at BB King’s Club. Deb sent me tulips when my mother died, I never forgot that. We had dreams of purchasing one of those long-arm quilt machines that are the price of a car and storing it up at your place in PA, and when Id’ retire I’d come up every few months and stay over and quilt up a storm all the pieces I would have created over the past few months. I am very grateful to have had Deb in my life and I will never forget her – her laughter, her friendship, her excellent hand quilting, her tenacity and strength till the end.

    My heart is broken for you both and for all of us. I dream of Deb running through mounds of beautiful green quilting fabric forever. Love, Mary Ellen

    ReplyDelete
  2. It's 1:28am Chihuahua, Mexico time, as I force myself to read this because of tiredness and broken heartedness, I wanted to mention Deb....GOD BLESS YOUR HEART AND SOUL FOR ALL THE BEAUTY YOU GIVE THIS WORLD AND MY FAMILY....The LeBaron/Marston Family!!! Please know that you and your family are in our prayers and your visit with us was of the most LOVING and INSPIRING we could of ever asked God for. We Thank Him for the Honor it has Been to have you as a Dear Friend! I wish I could embrace you now and comfort your heart. May God Bless you as you have Blessed us! :)

    Love Always,
    Dayer LeBaron Jr, Celeste, Dayercito (Guapos) and Sariah Josephine

    PS: My mothers Heart goes out to you! LOVE, NOTHING BUT LOVE!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am so sad and crying, Deb was all that was good in a person and in loving life. Even though as I read the blog's final days, we all knew the inevitable would happen. It is still a shock. I was happy when she got the ability to write on the computer with her eyes, I thought in some strange way it would boost her up.

    Deb was a friend, a mentor, a colleague and a Boss, but most of all a Friend. Deb has given so much to me and us all over the years, I could write for hours, I took some solace knowing she was there in her and Robbin's PA house, but it would be so selfish to wish or want her to stay with us in this realm knowing how much she is suffering. My thoughts and prayers are with Robbin and Ryan, and I will always keep your Deb close to my heart.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My heart breaks as I sit here next to deb, what a strong willed women, a fighter a lover and a best friend, my second mother. She has taught me so much in the last year and I thank God for giving me this opportunity to be able to be a friend to Deb.

    Deb has the best sense of humor, between the fake poop and jokes. We would all laugh so hard we were in tears. There has been many fun and inappropriate moments that I will leave unmentioned but always led to a laugh or a smile <3

    The last trip to North Carolina was hard on Deb (i can't even imagine what it was like for her) but some of our fun memories were made even on that trip. At night Deb and I watched The Birds by Alfred Hitchcock, we almost missed the plane the next day(it literally was starting to leave with out us), we made the plane stop a second time before it got of the ground so she could get comfortable, some people wern't happy but that didn't stop Deb.

    One time we took Deb to the dentist and while waiting she got impatient so she told us to make a lot of noise. The assistant was so angry with us, but we all couldn't contain our laughs. Life with Deb is never dull.

    Robbin,
    Deb knows how much you love her, she would often start crying and say " he loves me so much, and I love him".
    When I am here evenings and you come in at night to give her a kiss it just makes my heart sing with joy. Wow to love like that.
    Some of Debs favorite words are duh, stupid (not like she would call anyone that ;).) why?!?! Or that look she would give when she can't believe you don't know what she is thinking/wants and of course xo.
    Xo. I love that. Every time I would get a message from deb I would first look for the xo that to me was her way of saying I love you.
    Thank you robbin for putting up with all of us second wives for so long. I only live 4 miles down the road and anytime you are up for some over talking trying to take the words out of your mouth kind of visit don't hesitate to let me know. Also maybe we can have a burger night every so often.
    Thank you for all that you have done for me! Your home has become my second house.

    All my love,
    Kaela

    Psalm 23King James Version (KJV)

    23 The Lord is my shepherd; I shall not want.

    2 He maketh me to lie down in green pastures: he leadeth me beside the still waters.

    3 He restoreth my soul: he leadeth me in the paths of righteousness for his name's sake.

    4 Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me; thy rod and thy staff they comfort me.

    5 Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies: thou anointest my head with oil; my cup runneth over.

    6 Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life: and I will dwell in the house of the Lord for ever.

    ReplyDelete
  5. From Amy Smolek:

    Dear Deb,

    I know you are too far gone to read this, probably too far gone to even have it read to you. But I do not get to say goodbye in person, so I am doing it in writing.

    I know you have been very sick for a very long time. I know you were sick for a long time before that. I know you tried treatment after treatment, clinic after clinic. I know you saw your abilities shrink and shrink until all you had left was your eyes and your groan. I know much of this thanks to Robbin, since I have not gotten to see you in many years, not since that weekend after graduation when my family came to stay at the lake house. If I'd had only your emails to go by, I'd not know just how bad it had gotten, because you have never been one for complaining.

    I am so sad that you of all people found yourself trapped in a failing body. If goodness were at all correlated to health, you would be young and sprightly forever. And I suppose that's one advantage to not having seen you in person for so long––in my memory, you will always be energetic and expressive, enthusiastic and ebullient, which I think you would prefer.

    I remember you driving us to Trader Joe's in Media when you'd come to visit Ryan, and then bodily shoving us out of the way when we tried to pay. As a very poor college student, thousands of miles from home, your generosity and enthusiastic (some might even say aggressive :D) mothering were extremely welcome. Now every time I pass by the Joe's moisturizing lotion, I remember how you bought some for me because I'd mentioned my hands were dry; you will be forever associated with TJ's for me. I remember you and Robbin would always take us out to lunch or dinner when you visited, and how incredibly lucky I felt to be part of your orbit. I remember spending two Thanksgivings at the lake house, junior and senior year. I remember one time when I was making toast and tore off a paper towel to serve as a plate, because who has real plates in a dorm? until you took down a plate from the cupboard and laughingly reminded me that I was not at college and therefore could use actual dinnerware. (Isn't it strange, the things that stick in our mind?) I remember you covering me with a blanket when I was lying on the couch, and how much you loved the dogs. I remember that you sent flowers to me when I was dealing with trauma at the end of senior year, and how beautiful they were, and how loved and supported they made me feel. I remember how confused, verging on upset (more than verging, really––I think he was legitimately angry, ha!) Ryan was when you and my mom became friends. He would get so huffy when he was reminded that y'all talked (and maybe about us!) when he wasn't around. It still makes me giggle. I remember how you and Robbin invited my whole family to the lake house after graduation; you were so welcoming to the whole lot of us, and how lovely it all was. I remember good food and company, and my whole family still considers you and Robbin part of the extended crew.

    I don't think I ever got to see you in person after that. You were already getting worse at that point, but I was spared the last five and a half years of gradual, and not so gradual, decline. But we still emailed, and I still considered (and consider, present tense, and will continue considering, future progressive) you one of my "second mommies". I am so sad that I didn't get to see you more often, that I wasn't able to be more of a support for you and Robbin. I am so sad that you'll miss the wedding this summer; I am so sad that I will not get to see you again.

    This letter would not be complete without mentioning your generosity as my fairy godmother. I hope you know what a difference it made in my life, and how eternally grateful I am to you. I have not always been very good about emailing you regularly, but every time I drink that atrocious fermented vegetable juice, I think of you :-P

    continued on the next comment

    ReplyDelete
  6. From Amy, part 2:

    The shawls I made for you are small recompense for all you have given to me, but I hope they have kept you warm (and sparkly!). Making things for people is my way of showing my love, even when I cannot be there in person, and I hope it has made you feel a little more connected to me. I thought of you through every stitch, every bead, every pin, and as sad as I am that I haven't gotten to see you, I feel a little better knowing that a piece of me has been near you. By a similar token, I will forever treasure the beautiful jewelry you sent me this Christmas; even when you are gone, I will be able to wear it and feel like I'm carrying a part of you with me. Thank you.

    Your perseverance in the face of your terrible illness has been an inspiration to me, but I don't want you to think I think any less of you for laying down your sword now. I cannot imagine being in a body that cannot do anything, even speak, with a mind that is perfectly intact. My own illness is paltry in comparison, and I still find myself with days I can barely bear the thought of continuing to exist. Your strength and tenacity is absolutely unrivaled, your bravery here at the end no less so.

    I cry because I know how terribly Robbin and Ryan and Jenny and your helpers and all of us here in Oregon and everyone who knows and loves you will miss you, and because you will never get to use the big quilting room upstairs, and because sometimes bad things happen to good people and there is nothing we can do, and because my world will be a little dimmer, a little emptier, without you in it. I hope that these things do not make you feel worse about dying, but rather give you some lightness: you made my life, so many lives, so much brighter and better, even when you were suffering so acutely yourself. I remember you saying one time in college, when I said I felt bad having you pay, that I could return the favor to someone else when I was older. You have been a blessing in my life, and I will do my best to pass on your joy, your generosity, your determination and your love to the people in my own life.

    I will always admire you, I will always miss you, and above all, I will always love you.

    Love,
    Amy

    ReplyDelete
  7. Oh, where to begin expressing my love for and admiration of our dear Deb?
    When Amy was no longer in Oregon, but at Swarthmore, there was Ryan's Mom watching over her. I knew you would immediately step in and care for any problems that Amy might need a mom for when I could not. I recall that you made virus care packages for not only Amy, but many of Ryan's friends. How lucky were they?
    When Amy could not come for Thanksgiving, there was Deb, Robbin, and Ryan welcoming her to their home for the long weekend. I can't tell you how much I appreciated that.
    Amy's Grandparents and I were invited to your beautiful home after Ryan and Amy graduated. We felt so loved and welcomed. You and Robbin hung an Oregon flag on your pole, for crying out loud! Of course, that will never happen for us anywhere again.
    You brainstormed ideas and facilitated opportunities to help Amy get better even in the midst of your own health challenges. What a gift you have always been to her, and by extension me.
    You never stopped giving to any and all of us who love you and
    I will miss your presence in this world, Deb. Your zest for life has always been a thing of beauty.
    I have told you many times how much I love your Ryan. You raised a fine man and through him, his actions, and love for others you will live on. But, of course, he is a shining light in this world. How could he not be with you and Robbin as his parents?
    I love you and will always hold dear being given the opportunity to have a place in your world. I am the better for it.

    Robbin, you and Ryan are in my thoughts. You are always welcome in my home and I truly hope you will come see the beauty of Oregon someday, Robbin. Ryan, please comback and see again with Jenny.

    I hold you dear, Ryan and you will be in my heart over the next few months, in particular. I am eternally here for you-- your left coast Mom.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Robbin,

    My heart is breaking for you, Ryan, for Deb's family & for all of us, her friends. She is one of the most amazing people that I ever met & I always prayed for a miracle.

    Deb took me under her wing & we bonded in so many ways. I have many happy & wonderful memories of time spent with her; the advice, guidance & gifts that she gave to me; & how she was there for me when I experienced a major loss in my life.

    I have so much gratitude in my heart for Deb & for you for all of those occasions when you welcomed me into your peaceful home for long weekends where we hung out, ate healthy meals, watched movies, went to Harford Fair, went shopping & played Scrabble (just Deb & me), & spent New Year's Eve together more than once. A special memory was the weekend that I was there as a hurricane developed (Irene 2011) when you put my brand new Ford Edge in your brand new barn! I'm not sure if that was your idea or Deb's, but that was so thoughtful & I was very grateful that my car was safe.

    Robbin, you are in my thoughts & I hope you can experience some comfort from that. Bless you for ALL that you have done for Deb & all that you continue to do - you are her best buddy & friend. If you can get a message to Deb, please tell her that I love her & I am so happy that we are friends.

    That's all for now.

    Peace & love,

    Corinne Martinelli

    ReplyDelete
  9. From Louise Lyons:

    I worked with Deb some years back during her time in Nutley. Actually, she was my customer at a time when customers usually treated us like servants, resulting in the job being pretty difficult. But Deb was not one of those customers. She was straight down the line, collaborative, inclusive and ensured that I and my team understood the needs/problems so we could do our job. So my relationship with Deb was much appreciated. I reconnected with her last year via Facebook and have kept sporadic contact with her since then.

    Anyway, so why am I writing. I was forwarded your mail with the latest on Debs progress. I am deeply saddened to hear Deb is near the end of her life journey and at the same time happy that she will finally be free of the prison of her failing body. She leaves a gift of connecting people and specifically for me, demonstrating a true partnering, being a switched on super smart lady who gave me the encouragement to make my mark in IT. Please pass on my thanks to her and tell her she is often in my thoughts, and will continue to be.

    And to you Robbin, I dont know you but I am assuming you must be pretty amazing. One, because your Deb's husband but mainly because of the role you are now playing. I dont even want to try and guess how your life has been turned upside down but just wanted to say my thoughts are with you too. I wish you further strength to go through this next part of your journey.

    Arohanui
    Louise
    an old workmate from Roche Basel :-)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Robbin,
    You and Deb are the closest thing to family that I will ever have. I know how much Deb wanted this but in no way did I have the heart to be part of it. She knew Danny and I wanted her to keep trying. She made me sit for 20 minutes not being able to move. I was supposed to tell her that I would still want to live....I fell asleep. She said well? I said yes but I would sleep a lot. She gave me those eyes, like really? I told her before she meant everything to me but I just couldn't watch someone I love go through this and I would not be the one. She always seemed to know how to get me to do stuff but when it was clear to me something was going on I left after just losing my mom I'm in no way capable of end of life nursing for someone that I held dear to my heart. Deb knew and in no way did I ever mind taking care of her. I cut my salary in half for 3 years but it was worth every penny. Lori Osborn

    ReplyDelete
  11. Dear Robbin,
    When my phone rang last week and I saw "Deb Paul" on the screen, I knew it wasn't going to be good news and was so incredibly sorry to hear that the end was near.

    It is so hard to explain the impact Deb had on my life but suffice it to say that she gave me the opportunity that got me into a wonderful career and I will be forever grateful. But it was the little things she did to look out for people that made her special. She knew I had young children at home and I would feel guilty if I had to walk out of a meeting so she would watch the clock and kick me out so I could get home on time. The group she assembled in IM-NCD was more like a family than a department and she had a knack for bringing out the best in everyone. We are all still close, with Deb as our bond.

    I have been very lucky over the years to have had great managers, but I will never forget that when I was interviewing to work for Deb I asked Robbin if he thought I should take the job. He told me I would never have a better boss. I think that sums up how much he loves Deb and how great she is. To say she will be missed is the understatement of the year.

    Robbin - you have my deepest sympathy.
    xoxo
    Sue

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sue, I remember saying they were profane in that group and I didn't think you'd want to work with them. You replied that you'd bring a note of decorum to the group.

      Delete
  12. Peace & Love be with you Deb. Will always remember the good times in Bld 100 Nutley - forever a pleasure to visit & work w/ you and your team - well, except for the burning hot Thai dinners of course.
    Robin - thank you very much for sharing this blog - it is both humbling and truly inspiring. Our sympathies to you and Ryan. Angus & Janice Thom

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thommie and Joe! So glad this is somewhere we can all connect. Joe and I had the opportunity to say good bye 2 weeks ago. Deb, Thanks for being you. Thanks for your passion. Thanks for your love. I only knew you for 3 yrs. but felt like family as I came to you and Robbin weekly.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'm sharing this blog for a couple reasons. I think that people in the medical profession, after some time tend to loose sight of the human side of life and disease. I think we become too 'medical' and not 'individual'. I've been a nurse for many years now but it wasn't until I had the opportunity to care for a hospice client tha I realized how mechanical my nursing had been. Hospice literally forces you into nursing the entire person; not just the disease. Deb and Robin are amazing individuals, who have brought the horrific effects of ALS front and center and have shown the human side of themselves during this ordeal. My hopes are that more people in the medical community read this blog and are brought back to the initial reason they chose to be in the medical profession.
    I am so honored to have been a small part of Debs journey. My regret is that I didn't have the chance to meet her and Robin under other circumstances. I think we all would have gotten along well and would have had some fun.
    Annie

    ReplyDelete